Cardinals news from a Sabermetric point of view

For his next trick: Pujols and HR-SO ratio

After hitting a home run in yesterday’s win, Albert Pujols has 11 home runs and only nine strikeouts on the 2009 season. Homering more than striking out is one of those feats that is an unheralded — perhaps owing to the fact that it’s so seldom done — but telltale sign of greatness in a hitter. After all, it’s a measure of how often a player accomplishes the best batting outcome over against how often he utterly fails. Having more home runs than strikeouts (min. 30 home runs) has occurred fewer times than hitting for the cycle, hitting 50 home runs in a season and getting six hits in a game. Seventeen of the 26 seasons in which is has happened belong to Hall of Famers. And it hasn’t been done by a player not on steroids since 1956.

All that is to say that, for all of his feats, Pujols has yet to accomplish perhaps his most monumental. Twenty-eight games into the season, Pujols still has a long way to go to join the following legendary seasons in which a player has hit as many home runs as times he struck out (min. 30 home runs):

Year Player Age Tm G PA HR SO HR/SO
1941 Joe DiMaggio 26 NYY 139 621 30 13 2.31
1929 Lefty O’Doul 32 PHI 154 731 32 19 1.68
1934 Lou Gehrig 31 NYY 154 690 49 31 1.58
1938 Joe DiMaggio 23 NYY 145 660 32 21 1.52
1939 Joe DiMaggio 24 NYY 120 524 30 20 1.50
1954 Ted Kluszewski 29 CIN 149 659 49 35 1.40
1941 Ted Williams 22 BOS 143 606 37 27 1.37
1948 Joe DiMaggio 33 NYY 153 669 39 30 1.30
1922 Ken Williams 32 SLB 153 678 39 31 1.26
1952 Yogi Berra 27 NYY 142 605 30 24 1.25
1937 Joe DiMaggio 22 NYY 151 692 46 37 1.24
1947 Johnny Mize 34 NYG 154 664 51 42 1.21
1947 Willard Marshall 26 NYG 155 656 36 30 1.20
1953 Ted Kluszewski 28 CIN 149 629 40 34 1.18
1955 Ted Kluszewski 30 CIN 153 686 47 40 1.18
1948 Stan Musial 27 STL 155 694 39 34 1.15
1956 Ted Kluszewski 31 CIN 138 574 35 31 1.13
1950 Andy Pafko 29 CHC 146 595 36 32 1.13
1929 Mel Ott 20 NYG 150 674 42 38 1.11
2004 Barry Bonds* 39 SFG 147 617 45 41 1.10
1948 Johnny Mize 35 NYG 152 658 40 37 1.08
1936 Lou Gehrig 33 NYY 155 719 49 46 1.07
1930 Al Simmons 28 PHA 138 611 36 34 1.06
1956 Yogi Berra 31 NYY 140 597 30 29 1.03
1940 Joe DiMaggio 25 NYY 132 572 31 30 1.03
1925 Rogers Hornsby 29 STL 138 605 39 39 1.00

Phat likely won’t beat the Yankee Clipper’s 2.31 ratio of home runs to strikeouts, which may be the most unreachable record in baseball these days. Still, to even make it on the list in this free-swinging era is laudable. After all, even if Pujols is something less than all-natural, PEDs don’t do much for you if you don’t make contact. Will Pujols join fellow Cardinals Stan Musial and Rogers Hornsby this year? It’s a feat worth following.

4 Responses to “For his next trick: Pujols and HR-SO ratio”

  1. Lalagah Says:

    I’ve read that HGH can improve eye sight and hand eye coordination, but you know no one from the Dominican Republic has ever doped before, so I’m sure he’s legit.

  2. Pip Says:

    Yeah, I’ve read that, too. Do you have a link for us?

    Oh, and Pujols is from Kansas City, isn’t he? ;)

  3. southsidered Says:

    Jesus Christ, will you give the Pujols/PED thing a rest? I’m going to assume you’re a Nazi child molester until you prove otherwise.

  4. Pip Says:

    Obviously, some people are not going to want to read about the truth. As I wrote at the beginning of the season, it’s dishonest to pretend that statistical comparisons between today’s players and those in the past are as valid as comparisons between eras used to be. I’m not going to compromise my integrity because reality is uncomfortable for you to accept.

    In the future, if you continue to read this blog, I ask that you temper your comments with a little civility. I appreciate an open debate, so I’m not going to censor your comment, but we need to have it respectfully.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.