Cardinals news from a Sabermetric point of view

Ryan sets mark for ninth-place-hitter plate appearances

Tony La Russa revived the old pitcher-hits-eighth tactic Tuesday, and Brendan Ryan, the ninth-place hitter, started the winning rally. Almost as importantly (to us, at least), Ryan also happened to surpass former teammate and fellow shortstop Cesar Izturis for the most plate appearances as a non-pitching starter batting ninth (in non-DH games):

Rk Player PA GS OBP SLG GPA
1 Brendan Ryan 295 81 .313 .361 .231
2 Cesar Izturis 294 77 .309 .311 .217
3 Jason Kendall 165 42 .366 .386 .261
4 Aaron Miles 112 31 .318 .307 .220
5 Eli Marrero 109 29 .321 .381 .240
6 Joe DeMaestri 92 30 .413 .476 .305
7 Jack Wilson 84 22 .262 .295 .192
8 Billy Hunter 70 21 .209 .238 .154
9 Ronny Cedeno 68 18 .265 .379 .214
10 Adam Kennedy 55 18 .291 .340 .216

Most of the top 10 are Cardinals, of course; one notable exception is Joe DeMaestri. You’ve heard of him, right? Oh, you haven’t? He was the main ninth-place hitter for the 1957 Kansas City Athletics, who employed the tactic in 56 games, the third-greatest single-season pitcher-hits-eighth effort:

Rk Tm Year Games
1 STL 2008 147
2 STL 1998 77
3 KCA 1957 56
3 STL 2007 56
5 STL 2009 46
6 MIL 2008 42
7 PIT 2008 25
8 PIT 1956 21
9 PIT 2010 20
10 NYY 1955 15
11 WSH 1954 10
12 BOS 1952 9
12 BOS 1953 9
12 MIL 2009 9
15 LAD 2009 8
16 NYY 1957 5

In fact, those A’s were the culmination of a mini-movement in the 1950s toward the approach: during the decade, 10 different organizations (Orioles, White Sox, Red Sox, Yankees, Senators, Indians, A’s, Cardinals, Pirates, Giants) had someone other than the pitcher start in the nine spot. The 1955 Yankees even batted their pitcher seventh in a handful of games.

In any case, the 2010 Cardinals, despite featuring the all-time ninth-place hitter, won’t be able to match their team record, set in 2008. They can make a valiant effort, though: Including Wednesday’s game, they now have two games in which the pitcher hit eighth; if they keep it up, they’ll finish with 143.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.