Cardinals news from a Sabermetric point of view

Best World Series FIGS: Where does Lee rank?

Inspired by Cliff Lee’s masterpiece in Game 1 of the World Series last night, we decided to see where the outing ranked among the great pitching performances of the Fall Classic. We tweaked* the formula for Fielding Independent Game Score, so here’s where Lee falls:

Rk Player Date G Tm Opp IP BF BB SO HR FIGS
1 Bob Gibson 10/02/68 1 STL DET 9 32 1 17 0 86
2 Ed Walsh 10/11/06 3 CHW @CHC 9 30 1 12 0 78
3 Randy Johnson 10/28/01 2 ARI NYY 9 30 1 11 0 76
4 Cliff Lee 10/28/09 1 PHI @NYY 9 32 0 10 0 75
4 Sandy Koufax 10/11/65 5 LAD MIN 9 29 1 10 0 75
6 Howard Ehmke 10/08/29 1 PHA @CHC 9 36 1 13 0 74
6 Bill Dinneen 10/02/03 2 BOS PIT 9 29 2 11 0 74
6 Roger Clemens 10/22/00 2 NYY NYM 8 28 0 9 0 74
6 Don Larsen 10/08/56 5 NYY BRO 9 27 0 7 0 74
10 Tom Seaver 10/16/73 3 NYM OAK 8 32 1 12 0 73
10 Pete Alexander 10/03/26 2 STL @NYY 9 31 1 10 0 73
10 Rube Foster 10/09/15 2 BOS @PHI 9 30 0 8 0 73
13 Eddie Plank 10/16/11 2 PHA NYG 9 31 0 8 0 72
14 Deacon Phillippe 10/01/03 1 PIT @BOS 9 36 0 10 0 71
14 Hod Eller 10/06/19 5 CIN @CHW 9 31 1 9 0 71
14 Monte Pearson 10/05/39 2 NYY CIN 9 29 1 8 0 71
17 Blue Moon Odom 10/18/72 3 OAK CIN 7 27 2 11 0 70
17 Don Drysdale 10/05/63 3 LAD NYY 9 32 1 9 0 70
17 George Earnshaw 10/06/31 4 PHA STL 9 30 1 8 0 70
17 Chris Carpenter 10/24/06 3 STL DET 8 26 0 6 0 70
21 Mort Cooper 10/08/44 5 STL @SLB 9 36 2 12 0 69
21 Josh Beckett 10/24/07 1 BOS COL 7 27 1 9 0 69
21 Brandon Backe 10/26/05 4 HOU CHW 7 26 0 7 0 69
21 Frank Viola 10/25/87 7 MIN STL 8 29 0 7 0 69
21 Mike Boddicker 10/12/83 2 BAL PHI 9 30 0 6 0 69

According to pitching-independent stats, Lee’s performance ties Sandy Koufax’s 10-strikeout game in 1965 for fourth-best all-time — better even than Don Larsen’s perfecto. Talk about a double-whammy for Yankee fans.


*FIGS = 60+2*SO-3*BB-13*HR+Outs-BF. Kerry Wood’s 20-strikeout game, considered by many to be the most dominant performance of all-time, scores a 98. We’d also like to note that the great Carl Erskine’s record-setting 14-strikeout game in the 1953 series barely missed the top 20 above, with a 68 FIGS.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.